MAGA hat violated Hatch Act; Black worker’s BLM hat didn’t
Allegations based on other dress-code infractions also lacking
July 07, 2023 – The US Postal Service defeated a lawsuit by a White mail carrier who claimed discrimination, in part because he was treated differently for wearing a MAGA hat than a Black co-worker was for wearing a Black Lives Matter hat.
The ruling Thursday by the US District Court for the Western District of Kentucky partly turns on a rare application of the Hatch Act in the employment bias context. The 1939 law bars civil-service employees in the executive branch other than the president and vice president from engaging in certain types of political activity.
James Halbauer’s July 2020 suit alleged that his Black colleague called him a racist repeatedly after he arrived for work at their Louisville location in August 2019 wearing a Make America Great Again hat. She continued to yell at him even after a union steward told her to stop, and a supervisor later told Halbuaer that he would be escorted off the premises if he wore his MAGA hat again at work, the suit said.
The way he was treated contrasted with the treatment that the Black co-worker received when she came to work about a week later wearing a BLM hat, Halbauer said. She wasn’t required to take her hat off even after he reported it to a supervisor, he said.
That doesn’t show race-based disparate treatment, Judge Greg N. Stivers said. “Halbauer was wearing campaign paraphernalia that he was not permitted to wear due to the Hatch Act, whereas” the black employee’s “hat was not campaign-related and simply bore the name of a social movement,” the judge said.
PEN: So, left leaning judges, and others, think that the phrase Make America Great Again (MAGA) is purely political related. We think their true opinion is that the phrase promotes former President Trump and conservatives in general. Actually, MAGA has been used for years for years – long before Trump won office. President Reagan repeatedly promised to “make America great again” during his 1980 presidential campaign. He, too, used it as slogan on campaign merchandise. Even democrat President Bill Clinton used the phrase – “I believe that together we can make America great again,” said Clinton is his 1991 presidential announcement speech . In a campaign stop almost a year later, he called on voters “to make America great again economically, educationally, and socially.” But more recently Clinton has been suggesting on the campaign trail that the phrase is actually a racist dog whistle , one “white Southerners” would surely understand. But the phrase could regularly be found in the 42nd president’s own campaign speeches. PEN: Clinton’s reference to white Southerners, to me, is very offensive.
USA Today states, “The White House is continuing to use the term “MAGA” to label Republican opposition despite a federal watchdog agency’s warning that the language is a violation of the Hatch Act.
Halbauer also pointed to other allegedly unequal treatment with regard to his dress code violations compared to the Black co-worker, including footwear. That evidence similarly failed, Stivers said in granting summary judgment to the USPS. Read more at Bloomberg Law
PEN: The courts, or whomever, can say the use of MAGA in speech or in apparel is politically charged all they want, but in actuality the statement Make America Great Again means just what it says and nothing more. Because Trump, Reagan, Clinton or anyone else has used the phrase in any manner whatsoever does not, at its’ core, change the words to a political statement. Wearing both of those branded hats, or apparel, at work should not be allowed in any USPS work location under any circumstances no matter which political party is in control of the White House.
Rick Owens – Editor
PEN
The USPS employee who called the MAGA hat USPS employee a racist should have been fired on the spot. The MAGA and BLM hat wearers should have been immediately sent home and docked a days pay.
i agree in part to what you state in your rebuttal.No hat other than a usps logo hat should be worn in the workplace period! you get a uniform allowance for a reason.my co-worker wore his knicks hat and was immediately told to remove it or he would be sent home.unfortunately not every supervisor is born equal and to allow this kind of argument shows that this supervisor is a poor one!!! they allow any body to become a supervisor regardless if you have any people skills or not and they need to allow more experience like 10 years in the service as a minimum to become a supervisor otherwise more of these unfortunate situations will happen