Burrus Says What Went Wrong?

In the recent contract negotiations an often stated objective of the union was to “Save the Postal Service.” This objective, intertwined with an opportunity to increase jobs within the bargaining unit created the rationale that an exchange for future wages, rights and benefits was a step forward. The concept created a mindset and influenced the many union decisions over the course of bargaining. These were good intentions and in other circumstances may have achieved their objectives but the end result will be severe adverse impact on generations of postal employees while the future of the Postal Service remains in jeopardy.

The simple fact is that employees cannot resolve the Postal Service’s financial problems. With the next generation of employees suffering wage cuts up to 40%, the Postal Service is still on track to insolvency in 2012. Arbitrator Goldberg summarized the financial stability of the Postal Service in his 2000 interest arbitration award, concluding that it was the responsibility of Congress (not the union in wage concessions) to enact legislation that would secure the USPS’ future. The union’s focus on the needs of the Postal Service is outside the scope of the normal labor agenda and beyond the capability of union negotiators to make a substantial difference.

Congress is aware that the Postal Service cannot and will not survive without legislative initiatives. The Conservative legislators know this but they see an opportunity to reduce employee wages and move the Service towards privatization.

There is no rationale for wage reductions beyond saving money for the Postal Service. By any measure, postal employees have a record of significant productivity increases and have an entitlement to share in the savings earned. The amount spent on APWU represented employees’ wages since 1972 has declined in real terms nearly 3 percent while mail volume has grown 96 percent over the same time period. As a result, employees will deliver nearly twice as much mail at a cost that will be over 20% less after factoring in the 2010 changes. Wages of employees hired under the new contract will be less in real terms, indexed for inflation, when including the reduction of full time to 30 hours and the new pay scale, than that received before the 1970 strike.

Notwithstanding the union’s agreement to reduce wages dramatically, in exchange for jobs, a review of statements by the Postmaster General reveals the intent to further reduce the size of the bargaining unit in a range of reductions equaling 100,000 or more employees. The shifting of 10,000 or more positions from non-supervisory or non-bargaining to the APWU bargaining unit will result in a net, near term loss of 50,000 or more APWU represented employees, and unprecedented wage reductions.

Recent legislative initiatives, although misguided, reflect the recognition by Congress that labor savings will not be sufficient to “save the Postal Service” and without congressional intervention, postal finances are insufficient to meet its obligations burdened by future health care payments and low mail volume.

Despite the inadequacy of wage reductions to address the USPS’ financial difficulties, postal management is expected to use the APWU’s wage concessions as a pattern in other bargaining. With the APWU contract as a guide, the NALC and the Mail Handlers will face demands for equal concessions and if as expected, they resist, Congress will point to union recalcitrance as evidence of the need for regressive reform.

If the Postal Service is to survive, it is Congress that must act with or without union concessions to overcome the real obstacles to the USPS’ solvency. In a series of articles (Will the Post Office Survive), I have explored the obstacles and opportunities of its survival.

Recent efforts by union negotiators were noble with good and honorable intentions, but way beyond the scope of labor. Employee wage reductions cannot save the Postal Service.

Peace, Love and Solidarity,
Bill Burrus

Visit The Burrus Journal

One Response to "Burrus Says What Went Wrong?"

  1. Mr. Burrus,

    I always read your material with great interest and use it to gain a lot of knowledge just as I use to listen to you speak at events.

    I was a no vote as well as our Local but now I have to fight the struggle even harder for as long as I am a Leader in this Union and beyond I am commited to that.

    I agree that Unions are not responsible to negotiate base on the finances of their Company or Government. The Union should just focus on getting the best possible agreement for their Members.

    I look at whats happening in the State of Connecticut with the workers Union.
    The Union has gone as far as to change the Local Consitutuions in Special Meeting of Executive Boards so as to reenegociate a live contract due to treats of layoffs from the Governer. At Town Hall Meetings that Governor Molloy held around the State after his election, (With Major Support from the UNIONS) every meeting brought out the fact that each and every agency within the State was top heavy in the Management level. If the Governor was listening at these meeting he would of looked at the concerns brought out at the meetings, more then likely saved a good chunck of money with the cuts of nonbargaining employees and would of had to ask for less from the Unions.
    The Postal Service should be doing the same for it is well known and if I recall in your testimony to Congrees that there is an over abundance of Mangers all over the Country. If the Level of Management gets cut, Congress gets rid of the gross retirement Pre-Fund, a lot of outside contracts given back to Craft Workers, the Union probly would of been asking for a higher percentage of FTR’s in Level 18 Offices and up, lower percentage of Postal Support Employees with compatable pay to their co-workers and a better pay increase so the higher cost of health care would not take away the finicial gain for the Member.
    I truly feel we lost a lot of what was gained since the first contract was ever created for the APWU and now we have to fight it all back as if its day one after the strike.
    The strugle continues for all Unions and I believe is almost back to the street fights and bullyclub days of negociations. I sure hope not.
    Keep the post coming Mr. Burrus they are good readings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.