Postal Banking? Maybe Not – USPS Pilot Test Brought in Just $35.70

PEN: As we have stated numerous times…people who do not have bank accounts do not want bank accounts. They simply do not want to be tracked by the IRS – government – USPS – or anyone else. Progressives just do not get it. Additionally, we agree that the stand-alone payday lenders charge way too much for their services and this has a negative impact on the poor, but postal banking is not the answer. The answer is to control interest and fees charged by these type lenders.

From Government Executive –

The Postal Service Has Provided Financial Services to Just 6 Customers Through Its Banking Pilot

The limited program has brought in $35.70 to the mailing agency.

The U.S. Postal Service has provided financial services to just six individuals since it launched a pilot program in September, bringing into question whether the mailing agency will expand the effort that many progressive lawmakers and advocates have pushed for years.

USPS launched its limited foray into banking last fall at four post offices and with little fanfare. It allowed customers at those locations to use “business checks”—that is, checks with a business’ name printed on the check and made out to the individual—to pay for Visa gift cards of up to $500. The six sales using checks between September 13 and January 12 have brought in just $35.70 in fees to the Postal Service, the agency said in a filing with its regulator on Friday and provided a total value of $548.46 in gift cards.

Postal management declined to say what its plans are with the pilot moving forward, explaining any decisions are pending further evaluation of the results of the initial program. USPS said it will measure the success of the initiative based on customer usage and whether there was a demonstrated benefit to the community. Research from the University of Michigan has found that one-in-four U.S. Census tracts, which are home to 21 million people, do not have any banks within their borders [PEN: Yes, banks are not going to build in extremely rural areas]. Advocates for postal banking have highlighted that the private sector often charges high fees for check cashing services and that historically disadvantaged communities are disproportionately impacted by them. The Postal Service is charging $5.95 per check transaction and, for now, is only allowing the checks to be used for gift cards. Read more

More on postal banking:

3 Responses to "Postal Banking? Maybe Not – USPS Pilot Test Brought in Just $35.70"

  1. This is transparently a test marketing which is designed to fail. Only 4 locations, no attempt to promote the trial to potential customers (only signs posted in the physical buildings–I haven’t been inside one in two years), and the sole service offered is available to people without bank accounts at any retailer, without the pointless payment restrictions. There are many good reasons not to have a bank account which would not apply to a well-managed, useful banking service through a quasi-governmental agency for whom profit is not the primary motive. The most obvious one is that banking services are grossly overpriced, due to voracious profit appetites and unwise risk-taking, as well as the obvious ubiquitous debt and penalty traps, and fees which, while explained in agreements, are in fine print that they know most people won’t read. Credit unions are a great option, but not everyone is close to one for which they qualify, whereas a post office is near almost everyone. For those who aren’t close to a post office, transactions by mail could be very fast and cheap, since the postal rates could be low or waived, and the transactions completed without any movement of the mail beyond the local post office. But we will never know how many would find this service useful, because DeJoy is not interested in the program being successful, he is faking a test to prove that it can’t be.

    Just like you have your opinion – IMHO – there is not really a good and valid reason to have banking via USPS. And, it certainly isn’t DeJoy’s fault that banking has not came into being under his term. Postal banking has been talked about and considered for years and years…and, there are good reasons why it has never passed the first hurdle. Online banking already exists and is easy to access. If one is looking for free banking then look somewhere else…not USPS. It is a fact that the majority of those who are not banked never intend to sign up for a bank account…not at a traditional bank or any bank via USPS…they don’t want their money tracked and certainly don’t want the government or the IRS to have access to their income sources or actions.

  2. 1. We get it, It’s not a big secret: cash from under the table jobs, illegal activities, etc. You weigh your anecdotal experience with the unbanked …

    (and your anecdotal experience comes from what or where?) (& never going to bank) people you knew personally (versus all the other people you didn’t) over quantitative data (a national survey of 33,000+ households that also took into account multiyear trends, demographics, and previous banking experience [Figure ES.2], etc.) There’s still a large cohort of people who previously had bank accounts, but don’t have one now and would be open to improved access to services. My experience was live over 30+ years. Again, your experience is from what/where?

    2. Who said anything about “any postal banking” requiring large amounts of cash? The pilot only deals with gift-card style debit cards. Whether debit cards and other cashless methods would sufficiently meet people’s needs is TBD, but it’s not 1990 any more.

    It will not ever work. And, with all the complaints regarding USPS these days just imagine if they got into banking. BTW – banking, postal bank, or the like all mean the same thing…BANKING. Yes, the LIMITED pilot was LIMITED in function but most all of your cohorts want checking cashing in the mix…that’s check cashing not swap for debit cards.

    I will not address this again. You’ve read my opinion – I’ve read yours. Conversation is over.

  3. You may have stated it numerous times, but it don’t make it true: The assertion, “people who do not have bank accounts do not want bank accounts. They simply do not want to be tracked by the IRS – government – USPS – or anyone else. Progressives just do not get it,” is simply false. Note – not false – I delivered mail to extremely low income projects for over 30 years – numerous individuals became my friend. All of these chose NOT to have a bank account – I WILL NOT state why but it had to do with the manner in which they got their money.

    Looking at the actual 2019 FDIC report (https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/), which some of your links reference (but leave out this bit):

    “…about half of unbanked households cited “’Don’t have enough money to meet minimum balance requirements’ as a reason for not having an account—the most cited reason. This reason was also the most cited main reason for not having an account.” Most of those who do NOT intend to have a bank account would never reveal to you, me, or any other source as to why they choose not to have a bank account. And, there are those who do not want account tracking when applying for Medicaid, EBT, etc.

    Trust and privacy are significantly lower as main reasons; high/unpredictable fees also feature prominently. (Figure ES.3, page 3 of the Executive Summary: https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/2019execsum.pdf)

    As to why it’s only pulled in $35.70 so far? Hard to tell at this point, but the GovExec article you excerpted also goes on to say: “USPS has not gone to great efforts to market the availability of its financial services. Before the program gained attention in national media outlets, USPS only announced the availability of the check cashing service through signs in the four affected post offices. […] USPS has engaged in limited training for the three-dozen employees at the four impacted post offices, including a service talk and a PowerPoint presentation.”

    Lastly, the initial 4 pilot areas are all either urban or suburban (DC, Baltimore, Bronx NY, Falls Church VA) — none rural, and the limited scope of the pilot services ($500 max gift cards) may not meet the needs of the target audience. Banks will not build in rural areas and those small post offices are not equipped to handle the larger amount of cash needed for check cashing…which would have to be part of any postal banking. It just is not a good idea period.