The Postal Service’s regulator is asking what the future holds for a recent postal banking pilot. The Postal Regulatory Commission is asking USPS whether it plans to expand its postal banking pilot next fiscal year or terminate the program. For a flat fee of $5.90 cents, customers can purchase a single-use gift card worth up to $500, using a business or payroll check as payment. USPS launched the program last September at four post office locations. The PRC asked USPS why it launched the pilot without prior review from the commission, and how USPS trained its employees to provide these financial services to its customers. The commission seeks answers no later than Jan. 14.
PRC: Issued January 7, 2022
To clarify the basis of the Postal Service’s Annual Compliance Report (ACR),
filed December 29, 2021, (1) the Postal Service is requested to provide written responses
to the following questions. Answers should be provided to the individual questions as
soon as they are developed, but no later than January 14, 2022.
1. The Postal Service recently initiated a pilot program to expand consumer
financial services by allowing postal retail customers to cash payroll and
business checks in exchange for stored value gift cards (Pilot Program). (2
a. Please identify the date(s) on which the Pilot Program was initiated, and in
which locations it was implemented.
1 United States Postal Service FY 2021 Annual Compliance Report, December 29, 2021.
2 See Jory Heckman, USPS pilot expands postal banking services after years of skepticism,
Federal News Network (October 4, 2021), available at https://federalnewsnetwork.com/agencyoversight/2021/10/usps-pilot-expands-postal-banking-services-after-years-of-skepticism/.
b. Please identify and provide any market research or outreach the Postal
Service conducted prior to implementing the Pilot Program that
demonstrates a customer need or existing customer demand for the
exchange of payroll or business checks for single-use gift cards.
c. Please discuss the Postal Service’s rationale to commence the Pilot
Program without Commission review, especially in light of the statement
attributed to a Postal Service spokesperson that ties the Pilot Program to
“[o]ffering new products and services that are affordable, convenient and
secure aligns with the Postal Service’s Delivering for America 10-year
plan….” See Heckman n.2, supra (emphasis added).
d. Please confirm the fee charged for purchasing a single-use gift card is
$5.90, independent of the value of the gift card purchased.
e. Please confirm the maximum accepted payment for a gift card by
business or payroll check, including any fees for said gift card, is $500. If
not confirmed, please explain.
f. Please confirm that the only payment methods accepted by the Postal
Service for the gift cards in the Pilot Program are payroll and business
checks and not personal checks. Additionally, please identify the criteria
the Postal Service uses to classify a check as a “business check.”
g. Please explain whether the payroll or business check must be used in its
entirety in payment for one or more gift cards totaling $500 less the
number of $5.90 fees.
h. Please identify any limit the Postal Service places on the frequency of
transactions for single-use gift cards purchased as part of the Pilot
Program, and how the Postal Service enforces those limits. For example,
is a single customer able to purchase multiple gift cards with separate
checks as part of separate transactions?
i. Please explain whether the Postal Service is able to track gift card
purchases made by payroll or business check across locations or shifts. If
so, how?
j. Please confirm that the Postal Service will not exchange any portion of a
business or payroll check for cash, e.g., in instances where the value of
the check is greater than the value of the gift card(s) and applicable fee(s).
k. Please explain whether the single-use gift cards are returnable, and if so,
how the Postal Service refunds a transaction paid by a payroll or business
check.
l. Please explain how the Postal Service intends to evaluate the success or
failure of the Pilot Program, providing specific metrics or criteria if
applicable.
m. Please identify any plans for expanding the Pilot Program (either to new
locations or other payment methods) in the next fiscal year, if applicable.
Alternatively, please describe in detail any plans for termination of the Pilot
Program, if applicable.
n. Please provide the total cost, revenue, and volume data for the Greeting
Cards, Gift Cards, and Stationary products sold as part of the Pilot
Program disaggregated by gift card amount and payment method as of
the date of this request.
o. Please explain the types of training, if any, the Postal Service expects that
mail clerks will need in order to provide financial services, including how to
identify potentially fraudulent payroll or business checks. Please include a
description of any existing training for mail clerks that may be applicable to
the provision of financial services.
p. Please describe any training or guidance materials provided to Postal
Service employees at the Pilot Program locations.
q. Please explain the types of safeguards, if any, the Postal Service has in
place in order to confirm the validity of payroll and business checks, e.g.
the use of external companies that provide immediate, electronic guidance
on check validity.
2. In Docket No. MC2014-26, the Postal Service sought to add Gift Cards as a price
category within the Greeting Cards and Stationary competitive product.3
In its request, the Postal Service states that “[g]ift cards purchased at Post Offices are
likely to be mailed, similar to greeting cards and stationary,” and “that selling gift
cards at Post Offices will foster the use of the mails.” Docket No. MC2014-26
Request at 7. It further states that “selling gift cards at Post Offices qualifies as a
postal service, since sales would be ancillary to the delivery of letters and
mailable packages.” Id. at 10.
a. Please explain the Postal Service’s rationale as to whether customers
purchasing gift cards with payroll or business checks are likely to mail
those gift cards.
b. Please estimate the number of gift cards purchased with payroll or
business checks that were mailed during the Pilot Program.
