June 05, 2015 – A federal appeals court has upheld a temporary rate hike in the price of sending mail, but says the U.S. Postal Service can’t make the increase permanent.
From Postcom:
“Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night stays these couriers from the swift completion of their appointed rounds.” But a bad economy might. Or so the Postal Service worried when the recent recession caused mail volumes—and thus Postal Service income—to plummet precipitously. Citing exigent economic circumstances, the Postal Service sought a 4.3% rate increase from the Postal Regulatory Commission. 
The Commission agreed that the recession that started in 2008 was an “extraordinary or exceptional circumstance” that warranted some rate increase, but the Commission only permitted the Postal Service to recover $2.8 billion in lost revenue. The Commission reasoned that, by 2011, the Postal Service should have adjusted to a “new normal” business environment in which mail volumes appeared to be permanently lower than their pre-recession levels. The Commission also concluded that lost mail volumes could only be counted in the first year they occurred, even before the “new normal” arrived.
The Postal Service says the Commission’s decision did not go far enough; mailer industry groups say the Commission went too far; and the Commission says it got the order just right. We hold that the Commission’s “new normal” determination is reasonable, but its rule that lost mail volumes should be counted only once makes no sense on this record. We therefore grant the Postal Service’s petition for review in part. Finally, because the Commission’s econometric analysis was well within the wide bounds of agency expertise, we deny the separate petition for review filed by representatives of the mailing industry.
We grant the Postal Service’s petition for review in part, vacate the “count once” portion of the Commission’s order, and otherwise deny the petition. We also deny the Mailers’ petition for review. The case is remanded for proceedings consistent with this opinion.
Read Court Decision (PDF)
Idiots! Anything to squeeze USPS.